Optimizing EU Local Visibility: Navigating 'Places Sites' De-duplication
Why the Digital Markets Act directory carousel is a diversification play for European businesses.
The Google Places Sites carousel has become a permanent fixture of the European search landscape, following the implementation of the Digital Markets Act (DMA). Last updated via community insights on March 18, 2024, this feature prioritizes third-party aggregators like Yelp, Tripadvisor, and Golden Pages to ensure Google does not unfairly favor its own local services. For operators across the EEA, this shift has introduced a complex question regarding visibility: does appearing in these directory links risk de-duplicating or hiding your primary Google Business Profile (GBP)?
We have monitored these changes closely since the initial rollout. While some practitioners feared that Google might suppress a business profile if the same entity appeared prominently in the carousel, the data suggests otherwise. Instead of a zero-sum game where one placement cancels out the other, we view this as a fundamental shift toward a diversified local search ecosystem.
How does the Google Places Sites carousel affect local rankings?
In the pre-DMA era, the "Local Pack" was the undisputed primary real estate for local intent queries. A dental practice in Leeds or a boutique hotel in Berlin could rely almost exclusively on their Google Business Profile to capture mobile search traffic. Today, the search results page is more fragmented. The 'Places Sites' module often sits above or alongside the traditional map, containing links to vertical-specific directories.
Critically, this carousel does not function like a standard organic search result where de-duplication is common. In traditional SEO, Google often filters out a website if it appears multiple times for the same query to ensure variety. However, in the context of the DMA, the carousel links to the directory's landing page for a category, not the business's own website. Because the technical destination is different—a Yelp category page versus a direct Business Profile—the algorithm currently treats these as distinct opportunities for the user rather than redundant information.
Is there a risk of de-duplication for EU businesses?
The concern regarding de-duplication stems from the idea that Google might prioritize "fairness" by ensuring one brand doesn't occupy every pixel of the screen. For a 12-location HVAC operator in Dublin, seeing their brand name in a Golden Pages link within the carousel and then again in the Local Pack might seem like an over-saturation that Google would eventually prune.
We observe that Google is not currently de-duplicating at the entity level across these different modules. The carousel represents a "choice screen" for platforms, while the Map Pack represents a direct utility for the user. According to discussions on r/LocalSEO, businesses are successfully appearing in both simultaneously. The primary risk is not de-duplication, but rather the dilution of clicks as users are diverted away from the direct-action buttons (Call, Directions) of a GBP toward the research-heavy environment of a third-party directory.
Why EU local SEO strategy requires a diversification play
Treating the 'Places Sites' module as a threat is a tactical error. Instead, we suggest viewing it as an expansion of the available surface area. If a potential customer clicks the carousel link for "Best Plumbers in Madrid," they are taken to a list on a site like Habitissimo or Yelp. If your business is not prominently ranked within those third-party platforms, you have effectively lost that lead before they ever see the Google Map Pack.
This shift mimics the "Tripadvisor effect" seen in the travel industry for years. Before the DMA, Google fought to keep users within its own ecosystem. Now, the platform is legally mandated to provide exits. For an agency managing a regional restaurant group, this means a shift in budget allocation. High-quality imagery and review management on Yelp and local niche directories are no longer "secondary" tasks; they are requirements to maintain visibility within the Google-hosted carousel.
What this means for local businesses
To navigate this new environment, businesses must move beyond a Google-only mindset and embrace a multi-platform strategy. We recommend the following actions:
- Audit Directory Visibility: Identify which directories (e.g., Yelp, Yellow Pages, industry-specific sites) are consistently appearing in the 'Places Sites' carousel for your primary keywords.
- Optimize Third-Party Profiles: Treat your presence on these aggregator sites with the same rigor as your Google Business Profile. Ensure NAP (Name, Address, Phone) consistency and actively solicit reviews on these platforms to improve your internal ranking within those directories.
- Monitor Click-Through Distributions: Use Search Console and third-party tracking to see if your direct GBP traffic is dipping in favor of referral traffic from directories. This will help determine where your customers are actually converting.
- Maintain GBP Excellence: Do not neglect your primary profile. The Map Pack remains the highest-converting element for high-intent "near me" searches, even if it now shares the screen with the carousel.
Sources
Frequently asked questions
- Does appearing in a directory within the carousel hide my Google Business Profile?
- No, there is currently no evidence that Google de-duplicates business entities across these different search modules. A business can appear in the traditional Map Pack and also be listed within a directory that is linked in the 'Places Sites' carousel. Because the carousel links to a collection of businesses on a third-party site rather than a single business website, Google views these as distinct types of information.
- Which directories show up in the Google Places Sites carousel?
- The directories vary by industry and region. Common aggregators include Yelp, Tripadvisor, and local Yellow Pages (such as Golden Pages in Ireland or Pages Jaunes in France). For specialized services, vertical-specific sites like Booking.com for hotels or Houzz for home improvement often appear. Monitoring your specific category keywords is the best way to identify which platforms Google favors for your niche.
- How can I improve my ranking within the Places Sites carousel?
- Since you cannot pay Google for placement in the carousel, you must optimize your presence on the directories Google chooses to display. This involves ensuring your business information is accurate, increasing your volume of high-quality reviews on those third-party sites, and ensuring your profile is complete. The higher you rank within the directory itself, the more likely you are to capture the traffic redirected from Google's search results.
Related reading
